Are you looking for the best pizza in Buffalo? Look no further! We have compiled a list of the top contenders in the city that you simply cannot miss. Not only will your taste buds be tantalized by all of these delicious choices, but each restaurant also has its own unique charm and flavor that make them stand out from the crowd. Whether it’s a classic round pie or something a little more exotic, we’ve got you covered with all of the best pizza options available in Buffalo.
What is Buffalo-style Pizza?
Buffalo-style pizza is a type of pizza that originated in Buffalo, NY. It is characterized by its thick crust, which is usually stuffed with various toppings like cheese, pepperoni and sausage. The sauce is also typically a bit sweeter than traditional red sauces.
This style of pizza has become increasingly popular over the years as it offers an entirely new way to enjoy a classic favorite.
History of Pizza in Buffalo
Pizza has been a part of the Buffalo culinary scene since the early 1900s when Italian immigrants brought their recipes with them. Over the years, various pizzerias have opened up throughout the city, each adding its own twist to this classic dish. Many people consider Lombardo’s Pizza, which opened in 1950 and still serves pizza today, to be one of the first pizzerias in Buffalo.
Types of Pizza in Buffalo
Buffalo has many different styles of pizza to check out. From classic round pies and stuffed pizzas to Sicilian-style squares, you can find it all here in Buffalo. Whether you’re looking for something extra cheesy or something a bit more unique, you’re sure to find something that satisfies your cravings.
Best Pizza in Buffalo
So without further ado, let’s dive into the best pizza in Buffalo that you simply must try. From classic pies to unique creations, all of these pizzerias will tantalize your taste buds and leave you wanting more.
1. Brick Oven Bistro & Deli
Brick Oven Bistro & Deli is a local favorite that’s known for their delicious pies. This restaurant serves wine, beer, sandwiches, and brick-oven pizzas in South Buffalo.
They offer both classic round and Sicilian-style square pizzas, as well as unique creations like the “Firecracker” and the “Jalapeno Popper.” Their crusts are always cooked to perfection and topped with plenty of cheese and your choice of toppings.
The Big Time Spark Pizza at this restaurant is a classic, with its traditional red sauce, mozzarella cheese, bacon slices and pepperoni. If you’re looking for something unique yet delicious however – try the Bistro White! It’s topped with basil ricotta cheeses, arugula leaves and tomato slices; plus prosciutto pieces sprinkled over parmesan shavings and lightly drizzled olive oil & lemon juice to make it truly tantalizing.
2. Frankie Primo’s +39 Pizzeria
Frankie Primo’s +39 Pizzeria is a New York-style pizzeria that puts an Italian twist on the classic. This restaurant offers both classic round pies and square slices, as well as some more unique options like their signature “Buffalo Chicken Pizza” topped with chicken, mozzarella cheese, blue cheese crumbles and spicy buffalo sauce.
Their crusts are made from scratch every day and their pies are always cooked to perfection in wood-fired brick ovens. Try the Margherita pizza for something truly traditional – it’s made with tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil and extra virgin olive oil.
If you’re looking for something a bit more adventurous however, why not try the “Bufalina” – a delicious combination of roasted garlic, buffalo mozzarella cheese and spicy Calabrian salami. Whatever your choice is, you won’t be disappointed with the pizza at Frankie Primo’s +39 Pizzeria!
3. Mario’s Pizza & Subs
A Buffalo institution since 1947, Mario’s Pizza and Subs is known for its classic pizzas and Italian-style subs. This restaurant offers both round pies as well as Sicilian-style squares and their menu includes traditional favorites like pepperoni and sausage as well as more unique creations such as the “Blue Cheese Bacon Bomb”.
Their crusts are always cooked to perfection in brick ovens before they’re topped with plenty of cheese and fresh ingredients. The White Buffalo Pizza is a must-try – it’s made with ricotta cheese, and mozzarella, and topped with garlic, chicken, and fresh basil leaves.
For something extra special why not try the classic “Mario Special.” It’s made with pepperoni, sausage, bacon bits, mushrooms, and onions to give it that unique flavor that you won’t find anywhere else.
4. Zahz Pizza
Lastly, Zahz Pizza is a great option for those looking for something different. This restaurant offers pizzas with a variety of unique toppings such as gyro meat, feta cheese, and banana peppers; as well as classic flavors like pepperoni and sausage.
Their crusts are always cooked to perfection in wood-fired brick ovens before they’re topped with plenty of cheese and your choice of fresh ingredients. Their signature “Zahzie Pie” is definitely worth trying – it’s made with garlic cream sauce base, mozzarella cheese, mushrooms, onions, roasted red peppers and feta cheese crumbles.
5. Picasso’s Pizza
Picasso’s Pizza is a local favorite for its delicious and unique pies. This restaurant serves round and Sicilian-style pizzas as well as creative options like the “Cheesy Greek” with feta cheese, tomatoes, Kalamata olives and oregano; or the “Taco Supreme” topped with ground beef, tomatoes, onions and jalapenos.
Their crusts are always cooked to perfection in wood-fired brick ovens before they’re topped with plenty of cheese and your choice of toppings.
The Mustachioed Man pizza at this restaurant is definitely worth trying – it’s made with a tomato sauce base and sprinkled with pepperoni slices, roasted red peppers and mozzarella cheese. It’s then topped with a layer of ricotta cheese, arugula leaves, tomato slices and prosciutto pieces before being lightly drizzled with olive oil and lemon juice for a truly tantalizing flavor.
6. Gino & Joe’s Pizza
Gino & Joe’s is another local favorite that has been serving up delicious pies since 1972. They are best known for their signature New York Style of pizza, which is made with hand-tossed dough and topped with fresh ingredients. Whether you opt for the classic cheese or go all out with their specialty creations, Gino & Joe’s will never disappoint.
Their signature White Pizza is a must-try – it’s made with creamy garlic sauce, mozzarella cheese, mushrooms and Parmesan cheese. For something truly unique try the “Taco Pizza” which is topped with ground beef, onions, tomatoes, jalapenos and cheddar cheese.
7. Pizza Plant Italian Pub
Pizza Plant Italian Pub is located in Rochester, NY. It is a great spot for those looking for a unique twist on classic pizza. This restaurant offers both round pies and Sicilian-style squares as well as creative options like the “Quattro Formaggio” which is topped with mozzarella, provolone, Parmesan and Asiago cheese; or the “Spicy Thai Chicken” with spicy peanut sauce and cooked chicken.
A perfect crust is always ensured with their wood-fired brick ovens, and they top it off generously with cheese along with your preferred fresh ingredients. The pizza to try here? Buffalo Chicken! This recipe contains ranch dressing base, mozzarella cheese, buffalo chicken pieces and cheddar cheese crumbles – all topped off elegantly by tomatoes, onion slices and blue cheese crumbles. You won’t regret trying it!
8. Jay’s Artisan Pizza
Jay’s Artisan Pizza is a great spot for those looking for really unique pies. This restaurant offers both round and square pizzas as well as creative options such as the “Truffle Shuffle” topped with mozzarella, parmesan cheese, mushrooms, truffle oil and arugula; or the “BBQ Pulled Pork” topped with smoked BBQ sauce, pulled pork and cheddar cheese.
A trip to the restaurant wouldn’t be complete without trying their signature Margherita pizza! Crafted with a garlic cream sauce, tomato slices, buffalo mozzarella cheese, basil and oregano – this delectable dish is then finished off with a layer of freshly grated parmesan. Every pizza here is made fresh-to-order in traditional wood-fired brick ovens for an unbeatably crisp crust every time.
9. Hydraulic Hearth Restaurant & Brewery
Hydraulic Hearth Restaurant & Brewery is the perfect spot for beer and pizza lovers alike. This restaurant offers round and Sicilian-style pizzas as well as creative options like the “Wild Mushroom” topped with mozzarella, ricotta cheese, roasted mushrooms, garlic oil and basil; or the “White Clam” which is made with clams, olive oil, oregano and Parmesan cheese.
Their menu also boasts a wide selection of craft beers that pair perfectly with their tasty pies! Their signature pie – aptly named The Hydraulic Italian – is definitely worth trying. It’s crafted with San Marzano tomato sauce base, mozzarella cheese and pepperoni slices before being finished off with sweet Italian sausage crumbles, sautéed spinach and roasted red peppers. Yum!
10. Mister Pizza
Mister Pizza is a great spot for those looking for quick yet delicious pizza. This restaurant offers both round and square pizzas as well as creative options such as the “Fiesta Pie” – topped with ground beef, salsa, roasted jalapenos, tomatoes and cheddar cheese; or the “Taco Supreme” – made with refried beans base, mozzarella cheese, lettuce, sliced olives and cooked beef.
Their signature dish, The Big Kahuna, is a delectable combination of sweet BBQ sauce base, gooey mozzarella cheese and Canadian bacon – topped off with crunchy pineapple crumbles and juicy red onion slices. It’s deliciousness you have to try for yourself!
11. La Nova Wing Incorporated
It located in Buffalo NY, is also worth a mention for its delicious pizza. This restaurant offers creative options like its signature Pizza Sub – which is made with fresh dough, tomato sauce and a variety of toppings such as onions, peppers, mushrooms and sausage. For something truly unique try the “Buffalo Chicken Pizza” – topped with cooked diced chicken, buffalo wing sauce and mozzarella cheese!
No matter where you decide to go for your next pizza fix be sure to do some research on the spot’s specialty pies before deciding what to order. Whether it’s classic or creative there’s no doubt that you’ll find something delicious at any of these great pizza places!
12. Imperial Pizza
Imperial Pizza is a classic pizza joint located in Amherst, NY that offers both round and square pizzas along with creative options like their “Greek” – topped with feta cheese, tomato slices, spinach, garlic olive oil and oregano; or the “Spicy Chicken” – crafted with chili sauce base, mozzarella cheese and cooked diced chicken.
Their signature dish is The Imperial Pizza which features pepperoni, bacon bits, mushrooms and extra cheese all on a delicious hand-tossed crust. It’s simply an unbeatable combination! So if you’re ever in the area be sure to check out this spot for some of the best pizza around.
13. Mineo’s Pizza House
Mineo’s Pizza House is located in Pittsburgh, PA and is a great spot for lovers of Sicilian-style pizza. They offer classic slices such as the “Cheese” and the “Pepperoni”; but also creative options like their signature creation – The Mineo’s Special Pie which is made with sausage, mushrooms, black olives and pepperoni before being topped off with mozzarella cheese.
It’s a delicious combination that you won’t soon forget! So if you’re ever in the area be sure to stop by this legendary joint for some truly amazing pizza.
14. Mario’s Pizza Of Williamsville
Mario’s Pizza of Williamsville is yet another great spot for pizza lovers. This restaurant offers classic options like the “Cheese” and the “Pepperoni” as well as creative pies such as the “Chicken Alfredo” – made with cooked diced chicken, garlic alfredo sauce, mozzarella cheese and Parmesan cheese; or the “Veggie Delight” – crafted with roasted vegetables, olive oil, oregano and feta cheese.
Their signature dish is The Supreme Pizza which features a variety of toppings including pepperoni, sausage, onions, peppers and mushrooms all on a delicious hand-tossed crust. It’s an unbeatable combination that you have to taste for yourself! So if you’re ever in the area be sure to stop by Mario’s for some truly amazing pizza.
15. Romeo & Juliet Cafe
Romeo & Juliet Cafe is a great spot for Italian-style pizza located in Rochester, NY. They offer classic options like the “Cheese” and the “Pepperoni”; as well as creative pies such as the “Meat Lover’s” – topped with sausage, pepperoni, bacon and ham; or the “BBQ Chicken” made with sweet BBQ sauce base, mozzarella cheese and cooked diced chicken.
Their signature dish is The Romeo Pie which features roasted red pepper purée base, feta cheese crumbles and spinach before being topped off with pesto sauce drizzle. It’s a unique combination that you have to try for yourself!
16. Lovejoy Pizza
Lovejoy Pizza is an award-winning pizza joint located in Syracuse, NY that specializes in both classic and creative pies. They offer traditional options like the “Cheese” and the “Pepperoni”; as well as inventive pizzas such as the “Hawaiian” – made with pineapple chunks, ham and bacon; or the “Buffalo Chicken” – crafted with cooked diced chicken, buffalo wing sauce and mozzarella cheese.
Their signature dish is The Lovejoy Pie which features pepperoni, sausage, onions, peppers and mushrooms all on a delicious hand-tossed crust. It’s an unbeatable combination that you have to experience for yourself!
17. Bob & John’s La Hacienda
Bob & John’s La Hacienda Pizza is a terrific spot for pizza lovers located in Rochester, NY. They offer classic options like the “Cheese” and the “Pepperoni”; as well as inventive pies such as the “Garlic Chicken Alfredo” – made with cooked diced chicken, garlic alfredo sauce and mozzarella cheese; or the “Veggie Lover’s” crafted with roasted vegetables, olive oil and garlic seasoning.
The Hacienda Pie is their star dish, boasting hearty ingredients such as pepperoni, sausage, bacon bits, mushrooms and copious amounts of cheese all atop a scrumptious hand-tossed crust.
18. Artone’s Pizza
Artone’s Pizza is an excellent spot for Italian-style pizza located in Buffalo, NY. They offer classic slices such as the “Cheese” and the “Pepperoni”; as well as inventive pies like the “BBQ Chicken” – made with sweet BBQ sauce base, mozzarella cheese and cooked diced chicken; or The Artone Special Pie which features pepperoni, sausage, onions, mushrooms and peppers all on a delightful hand-tossed crust.
This is truly extraordinary pizza that you have to try for yourself! So if you’re ever in the area be sure to stop by Artone’s Pizza for some truly delicious pizza.
19. Gino’s Pizza & Subs
Gino’s Pizza & Subs is another great spot for pizza lovers. This restaurant offers classic options like the “Cheese” and the “Pepperoni”; as well as creative pies such as the “Chicken Parmesan” – made with cooked diced chicken, mozzarella cheese and Italian herbs; or The Gino Special which features pepperoni, beef, onions, peppers and mushrooms all atop a delightful hand-tossed crust.
Indulge your taste buds in The Supreme Pie – a delectable hand-tossed crust topped with succulent sausage, crunchy bacon bits, savory pepperoni slices, juicy black olives and flavorful mushrooms. Unparalleled flavor awaits!
20. Casa Di Pizza
Casa Di Pizza is a top-notch pizza joint located in Syracuse, NY. They offer classic options like the “Cheese” and the “Pepperoni”; as well as creative pies such as the “Veggie Delight” – made with roasted vegetables, olive oil and garlic seasoning; or The Casa Di Pie which features mushrooms, onions, peppers and sweet Italian sausage all atop a delightful hand-tossed crust.
Their signature dish, the Supreme Pie, is a culinary delight of pepperoni, beef, bacon bits, black olives and delicious sausage on a lovingly crafted crust.
Criteria for Best Pizza
When ranking the best pizza joints in any given area, several criteria should be taken into consideration. These include taste, texture, quality of ingredients, service, atmosphere and price. The best pizza places offer delicious options that are made with fresh and high-quality ingredients while also providing friendly customer service and a welcoming ambiance. Additionally, they should have reasonable prices so that customers can enjoy their meal without breaking the bank!
Overall, there are many great pizza spots across the country and each offers something special in terms of flavor and experience. So make sure to check out all of your local options before settling on just one!
Extras: Specialty Toppings & Sides
A great pizza spot should also offer specialty toppings, such as anchovies or eggplant, as well as side items like garlic bread and salads. Specialty toppings add a unique flavor to your pizza while sides can make it an even more complete meal. So be sure to check out the extras that each pizza place offers before deciding on where you’re going to get your next slice!
Finally, don’t forget about dessert! Pizza places usually offer sweet treats such as cookies and ice cream which can make for a perfect ending to any meal. Enjoy!
Conclusion
All things considered, the best pizza in Buffalo is a highly subjective topic. Different people have different tastes and opinions when it comes to food. What works for some may not work for others. But there’s one thing that everyone can agree on – Buffalo’s pizza offerings are second to none! From thin-crust pies with artfully arranged toppings to thick-crust slices smothered in cheese, this city has something for everyone. Whether you prefer a classic margarita or something a bit more creative, enjoy sampling the offerings of some of Buffalo’s favorite pizza shops to find your perfect slice
Other Articles
FAQs
Is Buffalo a good pizza?
Yes, Buffalo is known for its delicious pizza. From classic Italian-style pies to more creative offerings, you’ll find something that’s sure to tantalize your taste buds.
Who Makes World’s Best pizza?
This is subjective and debatable. However, many people believe that some of the best pizzas can be found in Naples, Italy where the classic Neapolitan style originated.
What makes a good pizza?
A good pizza should have an excellent crust with a crisp yet chewy texture, flavorful sauce and high-quality ingredients. It should also contain enough cheese to bring out the flavor of the other toppings without being overpowering. Finally, it should be cooked at just the right temperature so that all of its components come together in perfect harmony!
What is the difference between Buffalo and New York Pizza?
New York-style pizza is typically larger and thinner than Buffalo-style pizza. It also has a more chewy crust as opposed to the crispier, thicker crust of Buffalo-style pizza. Finally, New York-style pizzas tend to have less sauce and cheese than Buffalo-style pies.
Where does Buffalo NY rank in food?
Buffalo is known for its delicious pizza and other Italian-American dishes. In fact, it’s often considered one of the best cities in the country for Italian food. Additionally, Buffalo has a vibrant culinary scene with restaurants serving up cuisine from many different cultures around the world. As such, it can definitely be said that Buffalo ranks high when it comes to food!
Related posts:
John Battaini
Hi, my name is John Battaini and I am the founder of Wonder Pizza USA. We are the world’s foremost authority on pizza vending machines, with many years of experience and knowledge in the industry. In addition, we are also a collection of pizza enthusiasts with a lot of knowledge about PIZZA.